Final Analysis and proof of stalking by “gangs”: Who are the gang stalkers? Will the police/FBI/DHS/Et Alphabet investigate gang stalkers? Is gang stalking a “delusion?”

UPDATE 7-28-2020: ROGS apologizes for the many, many updates below in this post, but please bear with me, starting with this post here, where we see that the George Floyd protests actually began 12 years before his death, as his murderer, and his “police gang”, stalked a small family owned Indian restaurant in Minneapolis, where ROGS provided guidance, security, public relations, and other “assistance” to begin a now global movement against the surveillance and police states that the western governments, (FVEYs) have become.

In fact, George Floyd and,his murderer, Derek Chauvin were coworkers, right next door at El Nuevo Rodeo, which has now been burned to the ground.

1594582309778
Kabbuliwalla indeed. This small restaurant fielded more visits from police, FBI, DHS, religious, and NGO informants per capita than the Los Angeles field office– or Tel Aviv.

And, shitbag murderer Derek Chauvin and his racist Anti Democracy League (ADL) sponsored “dieversity gang” used to try to stare us down from the precinct station across the street, as my “partner*” tried to feed me envelopes of cash while sitting at the front picture window at night; and unmarked cars with self-flagellants in the parking lot across the street, too.

See this post for a direct reference(and use my search feature for other posts about Gandhi Mahal, or its FBI informant owner, or this post, where I name a few police and FBI “gang stalkers who used Fusion Centers and wiretaps to alter, manipulate, and “disrupt” political organization in that era) , and have a laugh about “marginalization,” mentioned in the flier above, cast back upon arch-conservatives and their gangs in policing, and their complicit multi-billion dollar NGOs and “community assets” who despise democracy; and of course my tribute to the famous Dick Cheney f-bomb tirade from many years ago seems fitting, dont you think?

Americas Right AND Left both despise and abuse due process now, so its a win for them,” whoever “they” are, lol.

ORIGINAL POST BELOW:

ROGS Analysis is a falsifiable strategic and dialectical analyses and theorem of organized gang stalking, based in the scientific method, wherein you can analyze cases of gang stalking. My evidence, and theories can be tested, and my analyses falsified or replicated; and in mass shooting cases, I’m batting around 1000%.

For proof of the veracity of ROGS-Analysis (ROGS-A) look at the recent cases of the Molson Coors shooting, the Virginia Beach shooting, and the recent arrest of an actual gang (aka a “posse”) that includes the exact suspects (police, retired police, and others affilliated with prosecutors and community assets) that ROGS Analysis predicts.

Read more about “the scientific method” here.

The scientific method is what scientists and others like ROGS, a former “doorman” who refused to be a police rat, and others use to prove, or disprove our theories, and as such, ROGS Analysis has repeatedly proven a useful tool in analysing gang stalking, and answering the questions “who are the gang stalkers,” and “what is gang stalking,” as we saw in the recent arrests of a retired cop on the phone with police, as he and and his neighbors and relatives murdered Ahmaud Abery in cold blood.

Police and security gangs are indeed a sad reality of OGS, and you can find evidence of that in many ROGS posts. Use my search feature, and search the cases of mass shooters and other victims of OGS doing strange stuff, like Omar Mateen, Cesar Sayoc, Ian Long, Stephen Paddock, and many other cases where security gangs,and police are implicated as provocateurs, and precipitators of mass shootings.

Related Reading: the Aspen Hill Wiki accurately documents police and security gangs.

For the reader to fully comprehend this post, where I shine a light on the faux-left wing stalkers** who targeted myself and others, as well as understanding my final analysis, you must also read the linked stories.

But perhaps more importantly, brief yourself about violent, militant bombers and murderers in the radical left, and especially in the militant, gender lesbian movement, and note the linkage between militant women in the many cases of OGS that I document herein,and asthe New York Post has documented, the bombers and murderers of the lesbian terror group M19, which “hid in plain sight” because of the biases of law enforcement agents of an earlier era who could not fathom womens violence, nor develop suspects accordingly.

The reader will note that I fully acknowledge the old paradigms of white supremacists in highly organized gangs, and that I personally took direct, covert, and decisive political action to combat a white supremacist police department, which had been infiltrated by racist Jewish and zionist elements,fro organizations like the notoriously criminal Anti Defamation Leaue tactics and tacticians; but that I now turn my attention to radicalized left-wing gangs, organized under what I call Kommunity Kulture Klubs and Kovens, K4. These groups (sometimes mistaken under the blanket term “antifa” obviously have different names for themselves,(indeed, one of the primary academic concerns going in to analysing these gangs is identifying the language they use to describe themselves, and their actions, as Professor Robert Guffey of Cal State has noted).

Related Story: Law Enforcement agents, the FBI, and other security and surveillance state players are at a “crossroads” as factions within these organizations compete to create manufactured terror events, and gain federal resources each time they pull these things off..

I have repeatedly documented radical lesbians, and beneficiaries of the Womens Funding Network and other similar, networked NGOs and DVIC profiteers present in the lives of shooters in the pre-ballistics of mass shootings, school shootings, and especially in the post-shooting “bystander interviews” after the fact of these events, most notably in the crybully initiated case of manufactured terrorist Cesar Sayoc, where we saw the left turn against one of its own, via the victim narrative of Baltimore police spokesperson Rochelle Ritchie.

Most notably, in the case of <a href=”https://researchorganizedgangstalking.wordpress.com/2018/11/11/a-bonus-13-in-the-case-of-thousand-oaks-borderline-bar-shooter-ian-long-dvic-slanderer-horse faced-gym-coach-made-him-run-13-miles-amid-constant-harassment/”the Thousand Oaks shooter Ian Long and the unusual, predicted use of the number 13 by one of his militant, self-appointed adversaries; and in my accurate, and verifiable predictive analysis in the case of the Virginia Beach shooting has demonstrated with empirical evidence.

What is Organized Gang Stalking, and who does it?

Organized gang stalking is good old fasioned mob rule, updated with technologies that were unimaginable just twenty years ago, and replaced with new excuses for mob rule, like countering violent extremism, or domestic violence, and other pet causes of western Jewish-christian societies, as we now see both altRight, and radical left gang stalking.

OGS is also the result of due process-free, uncivil, and unconstitutional policing tactics called “community policing” and “parallel colluding investigations ” (according to the fraternal and sororal organization Association.of Threat Assessment Professionals, ATAP ) based in massive database and private records abuses, and “high policing” which places actual military and police trained spies into the lives of targeted domestic civilians waging “weaponized investigations” aka “colliding parallel investigations” against individuals, and is a direct result of so-called intelligence sharing environment of countering violent extremism programs(CVE)that place current and former CIA /Mi5-6/Mossad, FBI (and their anti-democratic, secret police network of Infragard) etc. agencies and agents into the local, domestic theater of operations, which manufacture terrorists via intelligence agency tactical assaults on individuals, utilizing military derived psychological operations, and actual electronic surveillance, data manipulation, and political, weaponized technology aimed at targets, as documented by the Guardian, and the Intercept, and many more sources, post Edward Snowden.

What organized gang stalking is not

Organized gang stalking is not a delusion, in most cases, because behind every false claim spewed by psychobabbling fruitcakes like Dr. Tomo Shibata and others like her online, who are most associated with the delusional sounding psychobabble about electronic weapons, UFOs, and other discrediting gibberish, you will also find the following :

The psychobabbling fruitcakes like these examples here are are nearly ALL current and former police, security profiteers, and spies who worked /work directly in the CIA /NSA /FBI /Mi5/JTRIG /Mossad /etc.

* Women like Eleanor White, a former NSA employee; and who some say is not a real person at all, but rather, a cut out that anyone can assume online, an intelligence agency online profile.

* Men like Dr. Robert Duncan, former CIA, who practices, and writes about “mind control”.

* Women like Karen Stewart, former NSA, and an alleged whistle blower who no major media has taken seriously, ever. She and her pals started Targeted Justice, a website that prominently features all of the debunked gibberish about electronic brain beams and sattellite mind control (which is a euphimism for NSA spying on our communications devices) and who manages to squeeze the word “directed energy weapons” and other psycho-gibberish into everything she writes or speaks; but these like her who NEVER take up the cases of men like Ahmaud Arbery, and Darren Seals of Ferguson, MO, both of whom were stalked by gangs up cops, retired cops, and security contractors before they were murdered.

* And, in my own case, I had an actual Brookings Institute affilliated bully online, who is linked directly to both the US Air Foece intelligence squad, and the Mossad (thats how bizarre OGS is, when you do the research. I am a civilian-WTF is some retired military/foreign agent/spook and their pals cyber stalking and harassing me for?)

As we see, time and again, OGS is PLAINBIZARRE, whether its cops waging disinformation hoaxes like this, or spooks in the lives of ordinary people. Thats actually quite common in cases of manufactured terrorism too.

When I began to write ROGS around three years ago, as a reaction formation to the most famous case of gang stalking denialism ever written, where the partisan newspaper the New York Times published the now discredited journalist Mike McPhates gang stalking disinformation dangle, headlined “United States of Paranoia: They see Gangs of Stalkers” and quoted forensic psychologist and gang stalking denialist Dr. Lorraine Sheridan, I had no firm idea about how to answer the questions in the headline of this post.
1564328132878

Related Story: The average reader of ROGS blog will easily miss the nuanced discussions taking place between me, the researcher, and my many US Department of Defense/ Texas affiliated/Georgetown University/University of Michigan/Brookings Institute/John Jay College of Criminal Justice/NGO affiliated “followers” who have literally clicked the link to follow my blog, (and as I demonstrate here, in order for other researchers to understand the difference between Type 1 and 2 errors in delusional beliefs, versus documentation and empirical evidence of organized gang stalking by people working in and around the exact institutions that I indict herein , aka, proof of gang stalking such as my analyses of the use of the words “blackbird, raven, and crow” in the online dialectic of organized gang stalking, which was later revealed by The Intercept, and Reuters International news; and much more evidence which I present all over this blog.

ROGS Predictive Analysis is a scientifically and empirically proven tool of assessing cases of organized gang stalking, and validating an OGS victims complaints.

UPDATE Nov. 3rd, 2019: Woman shrouded in pixelation: the occulted nature of women AS gang stalkers, but also womens roles as purported intelligence analysts who wage hoaxes, and harrassment of all kinds,online and off, which leads to manufactured terrorism, as we saw in the recent case of the Pensacola shooter, who was sexually harassed, and who filed a complaint against his harasser, and who was then cyber bullied, and actually stalked online by FBI-Mossad affiliated persons before they go ballistic, and target the people who target them.

Most notably, click that link above about the Pensacola shooting, and note how the news coverage literally occludes /occults the name of the shitty, sneaky person who was cyberstalking, harassing, and tracking the eventual shooter. That news story is not unique in this practice of occulting the names of women who do illegal, unethical and bizarre activity, but is noteworthy because the stalker herself, Rita Katz,of the dubious terrorist hunting /terrorist manufacturing SITE Intelligence group, is herself a one person ROGS BINGO.

Please, someone, run this womans mug through some facial recognition software, as I encountered her in an unexpected place recently , as yet another NGO affiliated christian warrior for Jeesus tried to “save ” me; and that person, the son of a four star general.

Then, take a look at a ProPublica expose of a bizarre “mind reading ” tool that has led to false convictions, and is based in ponerology, aka junk science, and which was developed by a former Israeli spy .
1572767794810

Organized gang stalking is extremely bizarre, but in no way is it delusional once you apply ROGS Analysis

As you read through this blog, you will see that I have answered the general questions presented by Mike McPhates New York Times piece above, though each individual case will differ in aspects such as what specific institutions, tribal-religious sects, or local/national/international law enforcement elements are actually harassing them; and what technologies are actually used to target them outside of “level X” descriptions of technolgoy, where technical awareness is outside of the lay persons understanding of modern and actual spy programs in use every day on the internet, cell phones, and every other high tech device that reports directly to many actual spy agencies, via programs like Palantir Gotham,which literally monitors all of our online communications, or the Facebook feeds directly to Israel, and the infamous Twitter “firehose,”which police use to track, stalk, blackmail, coerce and influence activists online and off.

This “level X thinking” is actually, and verifiably far from delusional in basis and is just the laymans terms and descriptions for military grade technologies that are now targeted at all of our communications systems(with the vast majority of the psycho babble about other electronics being military and police and actual intelligence agency affilliated operatives deliberately poisoning the discussion online, as I have demonstrated repeatedly; and as the LA Times has begun to document hidden gangs in police forces.)

And, because I was well aware of police stalking, and how the FBIs COINTELPRO worked; and also aware that America is and has always been a quasi-democratic country with a two-tiered justice system where slavery and debt bondage now hide itself in the DVIC apparatus, instead of outright slavery, but exactly as how right wing scholar Stephen Baskerville has described, I had that as a starting point to begin research here.

Also, due to extensive previous studies of the Ku Klux Klan and its close working relationship with the FBI, and all other police institutions.

Such indoctrination and study is required in American public funded schools due to ADL involved publishing houses near lockup on school textbook curriculum and the narratives within them,as we now see the connection between mass shooter Jared Loughner and his love of “classic” literature via narrative control in college classrooms preceding his seemingly un-connected demise into alleged mental health crisis) and how current police work with retired police and others in an occulted fashion via “community policing ”to control, negate, or incite various social movements, or attack political speech, and its speakers, I used that as a guide.

But none of that could constitute “proof of gang stalking,“ from an evidence based scientific perspective. Simply knowing that one lives in a corrupt society does not prove that such corruption is targeted at one specific individual any more than such corruption is targeted at society at large by these hidden (occulted) elements of society; these hidden elements that are frequently referred to as “the deep state”.

So, how to “prove” that you are personally targeted by the “deep state” without actual evidence?

Well, as I demonstrate throughout this blog, after I personally wrote news stories in a college newspaper in 2001-2004 that directly challenged deep state narrative control,and funding sources for the fraudulent War on Terror, its religious fervor and slaughtering tone, and its false binary accompanying “Save the Women and Children” narrative; I then had my college newsroom ransacked, and more, and realized that I was personally targeted, and so later, I PERSONALLY allowed and encouraged these sociopaths to target me PERSONALLY, collected evidence along the way, and then applied that research finding to other cases, some of which are now reported in mainstream news sources.

Simply put, I was personally pinched between the bad policies of two bad presidents, who have demonstrably and inarguably damaged both journalism and journalists, as well as destroyed the protections of our United States Constitution, through the use and abuse of unconscionable, amoral black programs, online and off, spanning two decades.

And LOOK!

Exhibit A: the president of the United States LITERALLY parks an army of limos, and a full SS cohort a block away from my house after political events online, and offline that I documented, and which included a corrupt police department and specific, named dirty cops(you just cannot make this shit up. This event was covered in world-wide media)
1564329557079

Related: the historic mafia/mob affilliated police department in the,area where my gang stalking began

One complaint that victims of OGS are routinely gas lighted over is that they make claims that powerful individuals or their political or religious sectarian accolytes are stalking or harassing them. But few ever collect evidence, as I did in the photo above, as hackers in hoodies redirected my internet and cell phone communications, and morons online somehow knew that-and literally mocked me online for the fact that I had a I had a bust of John F. Kennedy on my backdoor. See this post here for evidence of that, as squad cars circled my house, and online shitbags quoted from DHS private contractor Gavin de Becker.

Exhibit B

I did have a list of names to work from in my personal case,some of whom, like Jame Doyle of Minnesota who was a very good friend at the time, and who, unbeknownst to me at the time of our initial meeting, was an FBI informant against Mohammed Warsame, a Somali immigrant who had “buufiis” which is a mental condition that translates roughly to “desert sickness” caused by heat and superstition, and isolation; and who had approached the agency to become an informant himself, claiming to have eaten dinner with Osama bin Laden, and more.

The FBI then manufactured him as an Informant against other Somali men, and Doyle, who had been funneled into the informant pool by local cops from Afton, MN, who caught him peeing in a park in the dark of night, and and charged him with a trumped up sex offense of “indecent exposure” which is a rite of passage in the US for affluent white males; a litmus test for adherence to Americas religious constructs of sexuality.

And I had other names from that era to work with, and many blog postings and comments that litter the internet with bizarre claims and misinformation, and more in the cases of others.

But the real evidence came when Department of Defense affilliated stalkers filled up my life, and eventually my Twitter feed
(which I have never disclosed here at ROGS, but have shared with other journalists; and a story that would require a seperate novel entirely)and then, I trapped, tracked, and traced these morons and sociopaths using Social Media analysis (SOCMINT ),and then, named them online and off (my latest military and think tank affilliated admirer here)and another recent “follower” with extensive DoD, and CIA connections here too.

The reader will note that my personal stalkers are both LEFT and RIGHT, Jewish and christian religious zealots,but also that I have named many other tribal /ethnic groups that utiluze gang stalking too; and so as an atheist I cannot help but continue to reveal western Jewish-christian fanaticism, and importantly note that I am not partial to any religion, much less Islam, though it is currently the bad Abrahamic insanity du jour.

Exhibit C: ROGS Predictive analysis scores BINGO after BINGO after BINGO as we see in the linked cases, and those cases derivitive of K4 affiliated gang stalking.

Exhibit D: The dialectical link between passive-aggressive crybullies, womens institutionalized violence, and K 4 gang stalking , and manufactured terrorism; and Jewish christian cultural practices, which is affirmed in my predictive link between concert and event security bungling around at the site of the the Las Vegas shooting by Stephen Paddock, and later, major media carrying stories about “five person teams” and Jewish organizations deploying military grade psychological operations on unsuspecting targets, and also, people who work in the DVIC trifecta industries of policing, narrative control/influence, and EVENT SECURITY with extra RIGS BINGO chips for noting that persons connection to white slavery racketeering, and “its for the children®” narratives.

You really CANNOT make this stuff up, it is exactly that bizarre.

Exhibit E : After I, the author of this blog became active in major and minor media, I personally began to change the dialectic of organized gang stalking at venues like OGS denialist Dr. Mike Woods blog www.conspiracytheorypsychology.com , and other places online too. In other words, I personally waged my own influence operation, to great, and demonstrable effect.

Then, discrediting narratives about me, and my purported character (or lack of it, lol😁) began in force, as some threatened to publish my blog material without proper accreditation, or as the FBIs own web masters peeked in here at ROGS, during a government shutdown, causing it to be identified as a “refferer” in my blog stats.

And its important to note that Dr. Mike Woods concurrence with the NYT piece has still not been rebutted by him in a single comment at his own blog, although he acknowledges the fact that Scientologists do utilize gang stalking tactics (and the link between Scientology is also affirmed in the case of Civil Rights attorney Andy Ostrowski as well ).

1575275087173

And, I personally participated, and am participating with a few major news outlets on other stories which I will not yet reveal.

So, like a RAT trapper, or a cockroach exterminator, I personally dragged the neocon religious zealots, and tribal-sectarian Wizards of Oz and a few real, and actual spies out of their internet hidey-holes (here, and here, and in other places at this blog), as some of them were forced to acknowledge their hidden internet operations, as we see in Exhibit D where NGOs like the Anti Defamation League work with Fusion Centers to target free speech, and frequently bully and harass people for bizarre and due process free periods of time until they go ballistic, like what happened to Asian American Mathew Riehl.

And, for later conversation, have a look at my most recent follower from southeast Asia, who is actually a Department of State, Georgetown University, CIA affilliated “save the children” specialist, for an eyebrow raiser about EXACTLY how the gang stalking dialectic works, including bizarre claims (deliberate disinformation) and especially the use of “coded” linguistic para-language. Gang stalking is, WITHOUT ANY DOUBT, Jewish-christian, militant and weaponized religious proselytization “on acid.”

Exhibit F: Before I wrote ROGS, no one, anywhere online or off had connected this form of “bullying on steroids” to the blurry Countering Violent Extremism programs, and the hidden mechanism of online speech policing leading to manufactured terrorism that the ineptly named Association of Threat Assessment Professionals calls,“the colluding parallel investigation” or the accompanying psychological operations that Fusion Center operatives are targeting at individuals.

But ROGS isnt afraid of some mystical devil, or adherent to western relgious biases, its attendant and fickle forms of racism, or sectarianism. ROGS is clearly a revelation that if anything, these fanatics have proven that there is no god, g-d, G -D, GAWD, Lord, lawd, or anything resembling anything close to a higher power or deity, or even humanity in their books, which is why they created the Total Surveillance state in the west to begin with , and proving that exact point: their version of a god is false, predatory, murderous, greedy, common group of amoral, petty, conspiring tribal animals and most importantly, poised at our windowsills, cock or faux phallus in hand wanking it to our innermost thoughts and ideas via internet voyeurism of a genuine secret police state; and as Edward Snowden has noted, these are frequently stolen, or redirected, or otherwise manipulated before they are formed, and then, denying that he/she/it was there as a voyeur.

Then, when I applied that research finding, everything fell into place after that, with many surprises, which I document throughout this blog.

So, in that light, Dr. Lorraine Sheridan IS an actual gang stalker according to her own biography at Curtin University where we see that she is closely allied with forensic psychology, and the dark arts practitioners of occulted internet stalking, such as cold case investigators and other true and actual “conspiracy theorists” who profile and cyberstalk and actually stalk their actual targets, much like we see in this example here.

Like this little piggy, who I also wrote about herewhere I link people who are prominent among the comments sections of gang stalking blogs but also, who were quoted in the LA Times in an article they appeared in a decade ago(follow that link); and cold case investigator and ATAP affilliated Dr. Christine Sarteschi, and also psychobabble spewing anti-pornography crusader Tomo Shitbata who is closely allied with the horse-faced antiporn neocon feminist relic from the 1980s lesbian porn wars, Catherine McKinnon of Michigan (and yes, Michigan has high rates of Google searches for “gang stalking and Michigan”) and all of these, integral in my thesis of high heeled policing related to the lesbian sex and porn wars of the 1980s–and all of that seems significant, dont you think?

UPDATE: Within days of me writing this post, a Michigan electronic billboard was hacked, and a pornographic clip of a Phillipino couple having sex played. This event was preceded by a similar event in the Makati financial district of Manila.

Then, one of my psychobabbling followers also made his presence known via an.inbound link days before.

Once again, ROGS scores a BINGO, in having linked gang stalking to pseudo-feminist neocon theology, and the re-booted 1980s anti-pornography and anti-prostitution money pot.

SO: Considering that one of the most famous mass shooters Seung Ho Choi was targeted and harrassed by none other than Eastern Star affilliated Nikky Giovanni, which Professor Emeritus of Waterloo University, Dr. Kenneth Westhues has documented extensively;and that other men like Mathew Riehl, and Scott Bierle, and Ian Long all also endured this form of womens institutionalized violence, crybullying, and the ATAP “colluding parallel investigations,” that are hidden from the public-ROGS asks: if you want to prevent mass shootings, and butter knifings, and “Incel movement” car crashers, why dont you, the reader, investigate the links I provide above?

Start here, where we see that the “incel movement” was started by a woman, who is a lesbian, long after men and boys like those I have written about here at ROGS go ballistic, after being blackmailed, compromised, or leveraged in online PsyOps-maybe investigate THAT link to psychological operations online, and how empowered women* are every bit as dangerous and violent and predatory as men? Because in case after case, we see mass shooters radicalized by these hidden PsyOps, and the people behind them.

In that light, ROGS asks: why does the FBI or the DHS not investigate K4 radicalization of targeted individuals?

And the answer, obviously, is that they are paid to do the exact opposite, because specially made high heels are very expensive.

Related Reading: Here is the text of an email that I received a couple years ago from one of these psychobabbling loons who used the WordPress contact feature to send me an email. Frequently, agents, social workers, and other “deep state” manipulators from these DoD and CIA affilliated NGOs totally slip up and I get their real name or IP, sometimes not.

And based on that, I was quite surprised at the amount of social workers (LSWs) who are involved as gang stalkers, under the FBI/DHS manufactured terrorism programs, or otherwise feeding the online dialogues, and offline shenanigans.

Below is one example of how “they” participate in forming a false dialectic space, signal to each other using the number 13, but also, they use stupid gender biased pseudnoyms.Most of them use Protonmail addresses, while the hackers that attack targets use the hack proof Guerrillamail system.

See if you can spot the (not-too) hidden number 13:

Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2017 at 3:03 AM
From: “Freddie Goodman”
To: (ROGS)@mail.com

Subject: [Research and data about organized stalking, gang stalking, multi stalking, community mobbing, and community policing.]

Contact
Name: Freddie Goodman

Email: [email protected]

Website:

Comment: Good god please help. They’ve been doing this to me for, I think 6 or 7 years. Does it usually go on that long? They’ve destroyed my whole life. Everyone thinks I’m crazy. (strangely enough, unlike many others, no one has diagnosed me with schizophrenia, though). I swear to everything holy, that they even put a directed energy weapon on a boat when I was hiding from them in the woods and zapped the shit out of me until I started screaming “please for godssake stop I’m going to die.” It stopped, and I heard the engine turn off. People think I hallucinated it, but I swear there’s no reason I should have been hallucinating, at least not that badly. I was not abusing drugs, though I had been having moderate insomnia for some time.

The point is, what do I do? I have hard evidence that some “agency” at least at some time has taken an interest in me and has spread defamatory content. But, the lawyers won’t tell me who, though they seem to know. Also, they seem to put “plants” in the psych hospital (I turn myself in for anxiety and insomnia, but in reality I’m just trying to hide from them) in order to torture me in there, too. They even called my social worker’s boss and admitted they followed me all around, but he wouldn’t say who or why. How do I stop this? How are so many others around me aware, but somehow won’t spill the beans? I’m absolutely shocked. I don’t know what else to say.

Please help. Thanks

Time: December 5, 2017 at 3:03 am
IP Address: 173.164.76.169
Contact Form URL: https://researchorganizedgangstalking.wordpress.com/contact/
Sent by an unverified visitor to your site.

Lastly: One of the unexpected treasures from my exploration of gang stalking was how easily and readily police are corrupted by international banksters and their NGOs. Perhaps this was best revealed by the unexpected link between high policing and libertarians. I am not a libertarian, and though I reject the false right-left binary of US politics, I find the link between corrupt police and international NGOs to be substantiated as early as the 1980s, in cases such as this, where we see a now deceased British Libertarian and intellectual, Tony Hollick stalked, blackmailed, assaulted, with entrapment attempts, and mysterious car crashes too, even naming George Soros’ open Society as a culprit.

For the record, ROGS is 100% for open borders, and one big happy world, the same day that George Soros and other billionaires like Jeff Bezos and Jeffrey Epstein and Rupert Murdoch, and The Last Remaining Koch brother© allow their many homes to be occupied by unwashed immigrants from third world countries, and they eat from a garbage can, bathe in a mud puddle everyday, and dodge a few bullets, as many of them (and even ROGS ) must do to merely survive.

In the meantime, I think there is a THIRD WAY to get things done, and those shitbags arent helping much.

*empowered women is a euphimism for militarized, weaponized police state activity that fronts women to do the dirty work of illegal activity such as online cyberstalking, offline stalking and slander, and actual spying as I demonstrate repeatedly, and with scientific consistency.

* that partner was himself an FBI informant, having been placed on the lists just after 9-11. I created him as a Gandhi styled peacenik strictly for public relations purposes, and he regularly held political, community, and inter-faith events thereafter, at my direction.

** The history of dissent always includes “co-option” of grass roots social movements by a host of bad actors working in policing, intelligence, and non-governmental organizations.

Classic examples are the Anti Defamation League spying on activists, while feeding data to the FBI and local police which still happens today; or the famous case of the CIA drug experiments to co-opt the peace movement; or the anti-democracy FBI manipulation and related assassinations of civil rights leaders in the 1960s and so on.

We see echoes of all of this cooption today, as primarily male activists are being murdered or dying in movie mystery styled “suicides” and homicides (Darren Seals and many more Ferguson activists, Duncan Socrates Lemp, Marc Angelluci Esq., and more.)

The real left is distinctly different than these corpirate sponsored Ford Foundation, Womens Empowerment Funds, ADL styled fake dissent, all of which hide religion, and bias behind “philanthropy.”

Moonshot CVE, revisited: I ask the reader (and Mike "the ADLs stepchild” ) Masnick to revisit each, and every ROGS thesis about ADLification, redirection, and “Jewish mind control”-prove me wrong!

“Internet content skews toward the virality of controversy, polluting the marketplace of ideas with vitriolic speech. The Redirect Method actually improves the online marketplace of ideas…

According to Mike Masnick* the progenitor of the Anti Defamation Leagues new go-to internet rag, techdirt.com (and Svengali himself would approve).
th(10)
Let that sink into your brain a little bit. ….like poison, or a horsehair worm, infecting a cricket….ROGS will still be here, awaiting your analysis.
Oh, wait- that quote comes from the paranoid racist people at the Anti Defamation League, specifically defamer-in-chief, Jonathan Greenblatt, who has now acknowledged EXACTLY what ROGS has alleged ALL ALONG.
And, the language echoes Mike Masnicks comments in the linked posts below.
So, dont ask lil’ ol ROGS about the link between the dialectic of “polluting the internet, ” and the Anti Defamation Leagues(ADL) blackmail and smear streams (that traffic in negative stereotypes about Jews, as Svengali mind controlling wizards)!
Ask Masnick, himself, if lil ol ROGS is polluting the internet (whatever the fuck that means ) as Mike walks the plank between internet fact and fiction, in the case of the ADLs Jonathan Greenbacks v Free Speech online, because every ROGS,thesis,about the #ADLification of media, AND the hidden “high policing” methods being deployed on mass shooters before they go on rampages is validated here, as ROGS now affirms the toxic ADL being directly linked to mass shooters, and inciting mass homicides.
K4 manufactured terrorism has now replaced the KKK as a force of domestic terror, via the creation of the mass shooter through online and offline harassment.

RELATED POST: Look at how FBI/CIA/ADL affilliated neocon terrorist/manufactured terror creator Rita Katz shows up at so many manufactured terrorist events, as a person whose company has preemptively cyberstalked and harassed people who eventually become mass shooters.
Is any US law enforcement agency monitoring her? Nope: because theres no money to be made from that. Cops and alphabet agencies ONLY get PAID AFTER these manufactured terror events.

The Anti Defamation League, most known for practicing defamation, and paranoid “anti-semitic conspiracy theories,” now ties itself directly to EVERY ROGS THESIS about sick, sad, racist Jews practicing online psychological operations against those who they target, stalk, harass, and pre-emptively defame online (with Techdirt.coms Mike Masnick highlighted as a polluter of internet discourse, via following ADL boilerplate defamation tactics):
From Smolokos favorite shithole, the ADLs own blog, I bid the ROGS reader 小心, and I ask that you excercise caution when reading the radicalizing racist hate literature of the ADL, the SPLC, and their sattelute news outlets and enablers, be ause that irganization, founded by notorious gangster Mayer Lansky, has sponsored bombings, and stalkings and other US centered Israelified mayhem for the entirety of the last century into the current one; and has been implicated as subverters of democracy since they famously spied on activists in 1993; and, ROGS has linked them and their intelligence agency accolytes, and Jewish stalking, AND redirection repeatedly, here at this blog(look at my posts about this person who stalked me on Twitter, or these ADL affilliated stalkings, ranging from Ian Long, to Matt Riehl, and even the odd case of designer fake bomber Cesar Sayoc, and more .)
https://www.adl.org/news/op-ed/can-google-search-be-used-to-counter-white-supremacy
ROGS asks: who is better at ROMPER STOMPER BINGO, the alt-Right, or white Jews who masquerade online as Zionazis in sheeps clothing?….

Can Google Search Be Used to Counter White Supremacy?

We’re co-opting the online platforms that embolden extremists who fan the flames of bigotry and violent fantasies to stop them before they act.
by:
Jonathan Greenblatt, National Director of the Anti-Defamation League
July 1, 2019
This article originally appeared in The Times of Israel
From hateful speech on Stormfront and Gab to the harassment of rabbis walking down the street in Germany to recent deadly violence at houses of worship in Pittsburgh, Christchurch, and Poway, it is painfully clear how online radicalization truly endangers communities. There’s a bright through-line from online hateful ecosystems to in-person violence. In fact, the perpetrators of all three of the aforementioned shootings were inspired by what they read online and actively involved in internet forums where extremism thrives.
The stakes couldn’t be higher. We must deploy every possible tool — from both the public and private sectors — to aggressively tackle growing online white supremacy as the global terror threat that it can pose.
That’s why the Anti-Defamation League is partnering with Moonshot CVE and the Gen Next Foundation to counter white supremacist and jihadist activity online. The program, dubbed the Redirect Method, will use advertising to provide individuals who search Google for violent extremist material with content that exposes the falsehoods of extremist narratives, providing searchers the choice of an off-ramp to radicalization.
Targeting content potential extremists search for — rather than focusing, for example, on what they post to social media — can directly address their harmful online behavior and desires. By providing them with credible sources, we hope to decrease the impact of extremist content and increase the spread of the truth, such as, there is no one “European” identity that is under threat. In this way, we speak directly to those who may be at risk of radicalization, and we incentivize re-thinking those ideologies with accurate information.
While it is too early to tell whether this method works, there is early evidence to suggest that it can have an impact on what content people searching for extremist content are ultimately engaging with and viewing.
Moonshot and Google previously launched a Redirect Method program for ISIS-related searches, which found that those who searched for ISIS content were highly likely to engage with the more constructive, non-violent content that was offered. This led to several thousand views of constructive materials in place of searches related to Islamist extremism. Our new project builds on this success while pulling from ADL’s subject matter expertise in extremist codewords and unique insights to lead the project.
The data on extremism is clear: white supremacist threats are increasing. ADL research has found that of the 50 murders in the US committed by extremists in 2018, all but one were linked to right-wing extremism and 78 percent were tied specifically to white supremacy.
Technology has accelerated the speed with which this hate spreads. Extremists have leveraged the anonymity and connectivity of the internet to move out of the shadows and into the spotlight. They have developed sophisticated, media savvy strategies to circulate their messages and reach a wider audience than previously possible. No longer is this content confined to the margins of society, online platforms embolden extremists like never before by creating an echo chamber that fans the flames of bigotry and violent fantasies. The internet now makes it possible for round-the-clock white supremacist rallies.
Throughout the next year, we will run thousands of ad campaigns across the United States. We will harness the vast array of content that has already been created by local organizations and individuals. We expect the results to provide promising insights into how white supremacists engage with online content and how we can use commercial tools to empower positive messaging to influence their behavior before they commit acts of violence.
Some people might hear about this and raise concerns that it could inhibit free speech. In fact, the opposite is the case. Internet content skews toward the virality of controversy, polluting the marketplace of ideas with vitriolic speech. The Redirect Method actually improves the online marketplace of ideas, not by limiting any speech, but by ensuring that hateful propaganda and intellectually honest information are presented side-by-side. Individuals are always free to ignore online advertisements, but we hope the alternative content will effectively challenge harmful ideologies.
There’s more to be done in fighting hate from wherever it rears its ugly head, but this is a significant step forward. We hope the Redirect Method will inspire tech companies, governments, and international groups to join us in creatively tackling this challenge so that platforms that are meant to bring us together to share ideas will not tear us apart. Together, we can be a force for good that prevents the viral infection of extremism from spreading further throughout our digital world.
If you are interested in learning how to perpetrate a swastihoax on yourself, or study crybullying and #fakerape, contact these guys:

Anti-Defamation League
605 Third Avenue
New York, NY 10158-3650
(212) 885-7700
Contact Us: www.adl.org/contact
Tax ID/EIN: 13-1818723
© 2019 Anti-Defamation League. All rights reserved.
Svengali says: I APPROVE OF THIS MESSAGE
* Mike Masnick and Techdirt.com is one of the extremely few online places where free speech happens. Unfortunately, it is only 90% free, because any criticism of the spy network known as the “Anti Defamation League,” or its octopus of affilliates, including spy agencies like the Israeli IDF, or the Mossad; or Israeli rech companies that spy on Americans from Silicon Valley (like this withered old cunt that spied on me via,Twitter, or this pathetic example of a United Nations rat that couldnt even shoot a digital camera) are “VERBOTTEN!”

The link between domestic violence and mass shooters: the Association of Threat Assessment Professionals piggybacking CVE funding in gray areas of law.

Dear Mr. x:
I have found the link between domestic violence(most of which is never litigated at trial, and all of which is little more than he-said/she-said) and the link appears to be to the Association of Threat Assessment Professionals (ATAP)and those who can afford to buy the outrageously priced $800 ticket to one of their conferences.
Link to August 2018 ATAP conference wich morphed the definition of terrorism to DV.pdf here
The Association of Threat Assessment Professionals (ATAP) is on record making a linkage between “multiple converging investigations,” and two other topics of interest: domestic violence and “the delusion of gang stalking.
1564329153702
Would you be interested in another insight into manufactured terrorism, and how multiple agencies have used Fusion Centers?
Especially, look at the case of Andy Ostrowski in PA, being targeted by people with “hit lists,” where I predicted this linkage many months before his last false arrest, and his lockup on now-proven false mental health charges, as he said “fifteen minutes after I hit send on an email” there are police climbing over his fence,and proved how OGS is exactly what I have documented at my blog (Ostrowskus case, you might recall, also involves Scientologists,AND Yeshiva University religious cultts).
1564328132878
I ask that you re-examine the issue of how these make-work federal CVE programs have slid the bar from ever-morphing term of terrorism, to the negligible and, nebulous term domestic violence, as they stalk, monitor, and harass activists and dissidents across states, time zones, andusingFusion Centers; and pressure some men so badly that they become mass shooters.
I have enclosed a .pdf file from the 2018 ATAP conference, and seek to point you to the talks titled:
Worlds Collide: A Fortune 100 Corporation, A
Former Employee, A Paranoid Gang Stalking
Delusion, and Colliding Parallel Investigations
– Brad Carnduff, Caterpillar Global Security, Russell
Palarea, Ph.D., President, Operational Psychology
Services, and Chuck Tobin, President , AT-RISK
International
TRACK II
Applying Domestic Violence Research Findings
to Threat Assessment Missions – Matthew Huss, Ph.D., Creighton University
What we see in case after case is that CVE is now being applied to DV cases, in an ever expanding net.
I think the names in the links above document that linkage,and provide insight into the “delusion” of actual multi-agencies from the federal moneypot making work for themselves; and, creating mass shooters along the way.
Best Regards-
ROGS

Spokane WA school shooter "on the radar" before shooting: Rotary Clubs, gun control, crisis PR, and 'active shooter drills.'

Try not to focus on patterns- some say that patterns can indicate mental health issues.
But one “psychometric” of the success of crisis PR in the classic Bernaysian framework is the causation of mass shootings, and the public’s ‘reliance’ upon mass shooter drills to ‘educate them.’
Oh- and trauma induced bonding, of course.

Related Story: Rotary Club “Cop of the Month ”NYPDs Valerie Cincinelli, indicted for plottingto hire a hit man to murder two people, one of them the daughter and child of her boyfriend. Ever notice how police departments and their accessory community club cheerleaders ALWAYS reward the worst actors in their ranks?

img_2520
A school shooting in Spokane Washington yesterday, on the thirteenth of September by a kid who had been “on the radar” took the lives of one, and wounded three others.
And, it was reportedly a janitor that stopped the shooting.
From UPI, we also see that-like many if not ALL of the so-called mass shooter events, an “active shooter drill” had taken place just the day before. Try not to….oh never mind:

Student killed in shooting at Spokane-area high school

By Allen Cone   |   Sept. 13, 2017 at 3:11 PM

 
“Annie Baxter, who has two daughters attend the nearby middle school, told The Spokesman-Review children were running into buildings and an alarm was sounding.
They did a modified lockdown drill yesterday,” she said. “I thought it was weird because they wouldn’t do [a drill] two days in a row.”

Rotary Club and Crisis Public Relations: gun control hit’s home at those who control guns.

Rotary Club blogger asks “Why do you distance your brand from certain industries or merchandise?

If I were a cop, a public servant, or someone charged with “public health” I would think that this pattern of mass shooters being “on the radar” for awhile, and then, the other pattern, where “active shooter drills” take place “coincidentally” close to these events would be an indicator that something is amiss. You can research that ‘amissing’ link yourself, but try not to make yourself…oh never mind.
And what might that something be that is amiss?
I dunno- I’m jus’ doin’ mah’ job as a blogger. I dunno. They don’t pay me enough to figure it all out. But from what I can gauge, here are some links below- and I welcome any and all refutation, or alternative explanations, if such can be found… which they can’t be, other than these are part of the OGS framework, and the associated “mysterious and hidden processes” of those who have placed themselves as God, hidden behind every internet transaction, and every online discourse, and pre-empted the Constitutional due processes, and the Bill of Rights guarantees, and, …etc.
HEY! I have an idea! Let’s ask the Rotary Club’s Internationale’ about “who sponsors mass shooter events”!!!
Hmmmm….
Let’s first look at “brand management, Rotary Clubs, and gun control lobbyists

Rotary and Weapons (from a blog post initially entitled  Rotary International Tells Clubs to Drop their Guns)

Why do you distance your brand from certain industries or merchandise? Obviously, because you feel that a connection could potentially hurt it. In this singling out of “weapons” it is clear that the Board thinks that Rotary is universally negatively impacted by a Club’s use of the Rotary logo in an advertisement for a Club fundraiser in which a rifle and archery bow are displayed, alongside a sponsor’s logo for a local gun and archery shop. To those of us who think differently, the opposite is true.
This is a revised version of the post I made on Monday, Feb. 27. Since my initial post, which was based on a Feb. 23 article “Rotary International Tells Clubs to Drop their Guns” by Larry Keane on the National Shooting Sports Foundation’s website, official Rotary documents have become known which support Mr. Keane’s article. http://www.nssfblog.com/rotary-international-tells-clubs-to-drop-their-guns/  Also, the rapid spread of the details of the Board decision has created much concern and anger among many US Rotarians, to the point that it is rumored that the Board will be holding an emergency meeting to discuss the situation as it stands now.
After my initial post, and an abbreviated version on the LinkedIn Official RI Group, I received some word that the information was incorrect, and that this was a “regional” decision not affecting the US. Since it appeared to come from sources who would know, I pulled my LinkedIn thread, and put a note on the post here. Subsequent to that, two RI documents came to me: a FAQ on Rotary’s Weapons Policy, and an item titled “B-16 Code Amendments: Weapons and Rotary Clubs, Districts and Other Rotary Entities”.  What follows is based upon those documents.

 
Crisis PR, gun control, and ‘amissing links.’
*The search terms travis air force base shooting and “rotary club” returns just over 56,000 links.
*There are 122,000 Google hits for the phrase “rotary cub sponsors active shooter event”
*Here is a literal few of those links- do you see a growing connection yet?:

Honolulu Police Dept. Presents “Active Shooters”

Police Partner with Rotary to Provide Free Active Shooter Training to Community

Heights police officer shares tips for handling active-shooter events

 
Hmmmm…. those links….
Active Shooter One Pager
From Mother Jones: Active Shooter drills, trace formation, and crisis PR interact to induce trauma, and then, trauma bonding

Active Shooter Drills Don’t Really Prepare People, But They Do Make Them Cry


MJ: “In the wake of the nation’s many recent mass shootings, and in the absence of any meaningful gun control that might stem them, employers and schools have started training their staff to respond should a madman with a gun turn up on their doorsteps. “Active shooter” drills have become the norm in many school districts and downtown office buildings; in many schools, such drills are now mandated by the state. But it turns out that bringing SWAT teams into buildings to simulate an active shooter situation doesn’t always make people feel safer. In fact, according to the Wall Street Journal, such simulations have seriously traumatized and occasionally injured people, sparking a wave of lawsuits.
The Journal tells several amazing stories of people who were injured or utterly freaked out during such drills, which often weren’t announced ahead of time. One involves a Colorado nursing home employee whom a man forced at gunpoint into an empty room at work. The “shooter” was actually a local cop and the gun was fake, but the nurse was so scared that even when the “shooter” finally identified himself as a cop after she started crying and begging for her life, she wasn’t really sure he was telling the truth. She was so traumatized that she had to quit her job and has since filed a lawsuit against the nursing home.”
 
 
 

Psychiatry's BIG "we are junk science" problem and artificial intelligence

Few doubt that psychiatry and psychology are fraught with junk science, or are as fields of study, politically motivated tools of corporate, secular and even sometimes, cultic religious  interests. Indeed, considering the non-secular and perverse narcisssim of Sigmund Freud-himself fueled by cocaine- and his nephew, the great Public Relation’s hypnotist Edward Bernay’s, we see that much of the last century and even today, these fields are little more than ahistorical political sociology with drugs and PR applied to, or around, and directed at the individual experience as a tool of silencing or criminalization of speech, and speakers- much like police science itself.
And all of that, mediated by the gate keeping of narrative that policing -and in the case of OGS especially-the hidden mechanism’s of social control that exert themselves when “mind control”and influence operations via narrative distortion and co-option takes place “at the gate,” which is the person who will claim OGS victimization( I am currently seeking an interview with a several times convicted felon who cliams that he is enduring an attempt to force him to confess to an unsolved child homicide from the 1990’s. He resides in a city that operated a “black site,” where victims were tortured and abused into false confessions.)
In the case of minigh dimol, aka waterinch, we have one persons online testimony to the farce that rehab clinics and their associated echo chamber of psychiatry and psychology attempting to control narrative in a systematic assassination of “the individual” for the direct benefit of the industrial complex of Big Pharma. This destruction of narrative is not a new phenomenon, as psychology has long grappled with knowledge that, in order to be even one drop better than sociology or Svengali science, they would need that extra “something,” to validate their own narrative-that they are a science.Police power functions this way, but so to does junk science which is a lie that travels the world a thousand times before the truth wakes up.
While psychiatry does have a certain political utility, and sometimes, works to envelope the stories of the poor and the disadvantaged in rationalizations that otherwise would not have protection in the wider society, the simple fact is that psychology is little more than sociology with official prescriptions from Big Pharma dope dealers.
And there is very little irony lost on “criminals” and  “drug addicts” and others who encounter legal settings in the form of court rooms, custody hearings,  or other legal attempts to “bypass their humanity and their narrative” aka “transhumanism,” and put in it’s place another thing that has more “utility for the greater good”: aka systemic gate l keeping and control of individual narrative.
Many is the man or woman who has been arrested and dragged into court over the last century as a deviant and a criminal, only to be told that they need to get off of “Mary Juana” or some other club drug such as MDMA as we saw in te case of minigh dimol, and get ON Prozac, or some other drug-of-the-month-club drug that Big Pharma is using to experiment on people.
Never mind the many notorious failures of prescription drugs, or how they are polluting the seas, and never mind that these drugs are themselves time and time again shown to be little better than Mary Juana at controlling the body politic of self-prescribers and “dual diagnoses” people for whom Mary has always worked just fine, and for whom Jim Beam does just the trick, better than any pill of the month. Most studies conclude that Mary and Jim don’t poison the oceans, or the people that use them with discretion.
And it is at the juncture where artificial intelligence meets the internet where we see what a monstrosity “predictive software” like Peter Thiel’s Palantir databases and their manipulative features that can be programmed to form situations of influence and custodial control operations; and DataMinr technology which is programmed to monitor “thought’s” and infer “actions” in real time, like Media Sonar-which was and is used by Fusion Center operatives to control, contain, monitor and influence activists until Twitter cut them off, and Moonshot CVE that is used by advertisers and corporate interests AS WELL AS the many LEO’s around the world that have foregone the “protect and serve” model of policing in favor of a “seize it all, exploit it all, capitalize on it all ” model of policing, to LITERALLY target SPECIFIC INDIVIDUALS and their “ideologies,” as much as they target actual real estate.
And psychology is truly in on it at every level, thick as thieves and fat as rats, and we know this based on the cases of Jessen and Mitchell, the angel of death Joseph Mengele, MKULTRA’s Scottish knight in academic armor DE Cameron, and now Lorraine Sheridan and David V. James and Elizabeth Dietrich that seek to overlay the pseudo-science of psychology over the suffering of targeted individuals of organized gang stalking.
This political abuse of psychology begins when we look at the key component of “schizophrenic narrative,” which has historically been a trouble zone for psychologists, especially in the heyday of CIA psychiatry where D.E. Cameron, first in Europe, and later at the notorious McGill University human torture and experimentation facility in Canada.  So, Cameron and others like the CIA’s official poisoner, the LSD doctor Sidney Gottlieb first diagnosed an entire nation (Germany) with mental illness, and that illness was, apparently, “the patriarchy,” aka “the warrior class,” and then, used children in experiments of all kinds-because in lieu of father’s now decapitated, the children of “the future” were then and are now in their sights.
As transhumanist types like Sheridan and James; and their progenitors Mengele and Gottlieb and especially Cameron, an heir kindred Mitchell and Jessen, for whom removing the “human” from the “experience” is a main goal, as they seek to replace, alter, medicate or otherwise mediate around the lived, human experience that exists in an individual mind; or to create it as a “hive” to be exploited by artificial intelligence in the case of Thiel and his intelligence cult, we see the field of robotics struggling with a unique problem: the problem that psychiatry has always managed to side step, which is the “human soul,” which is based in longevity of memory, and human experience that is sorted out and mediated through human filters within the brain that are stilll entirely unknown, and under-explored-precisely because psychiatry has been medicating AROUND this unknown.
Here below, wehave a study that encapsulates this problem in robotics- the problem of memory, longevity, and lived experience coalescing to form a “whole,”  from Phoebe Sengers:
 
Schizophrenia and Narrative in Artificial Agents
Phoebe Sengers
From: Leonardo
Volume 35, Number 4, August 2002
pp. 427-431
In lieu of an abstract, here is a brief excerpt of the content:

Schizophrenia and Narrative in Artificial Agents

Phoebe Sengers (bio)
Abstract
Artificial-agent technology has become commonplace in technical research from computer graphics to interface design and in popular culture through the Web and computer games. On the one hand, the population of the Web and our PCs with characters who reflect us can be seen as a humanization of a previously purely mechanical interface. On the other hand, the mechanization of subjectivity carries the danger of simply reducing the human to the machine. The author argues that predominant artificial intelligence (AI) approaches to modeling agents are based on an erasure of subjectivity analogous to that which appears when people are subjected to institutionalization. The result is agent behavior that is fragmented, depersonalized, lifeless and incomprehensible. Approaching the problem using a hybrid of critical theory and AI agent technology, the author argues that agent behavior should be narratively understandable; she presents a new agent architecture that structures behavior to be comprehensible as narrative.

The premise of this work is that there is something deeply missing from artificial intelligence (AI) or, more specifically, from the currently dominant ways of building artificial agents. This uncomfortable intuition has been with me for a long time, although for most of that time I was not able to articulate it clearly. Artificial agents seem to be lacking a primeval awareness, a coherence of action over time, something one might, for lack of a better metaphor, term “soul.”
Roboticist Rodney Brooks expressed this worry eloquently:

Perhaps it is the case that all the approaches to building intelligent systems are just completely off-base, and are doomed to fail. . . . [C]ertainly it is the case that all biological systems . . . [b]ehave in a way which just simply seems life-like in a way that our robots never do.

Perhaps we have all missed some organizing principle of biological systems, or some general truth about them. Perhaps there is a way of looking at biological systems which will illuminate an inherent necessity in some aspect of the interactions of their parts that is completely missing from our artificial systems. . . . [P]erhaps we are currently missing the juice of life [1].

Here, I argue that the “juice” that we are missing is narrative. The divide-and-conquer methodologies currently used to design artificial agents result in fragmented, depersonalized behavior, which mimics the fragmentation and depersonalization of schizophrenia seen in institutional psychiatry. Anti-psychiatry and narrative psychology suggest that the fundamental problem for both schizophrenic patients and agents is that observers have difficulty understanding them narratively. This motivates my work on a narrative agent architecture, the Expressivator, which structures agent behavior to support narrative, thereby enabling the creation of agents that are intentionally comprehensible.

The Problem

Building complex, integrated artificial agents is one of the dreams of AI. Classically, complex agents are constructed by identifying functional components—natural-language processing, vision, planning, etc.—designing and building each separately and then integrating them into an agent. More recently, some practitioners have argued that the various components of an agent strongly constrain one another and that the complex functionalities of classical AI cannot be easily coordinated into a whole system. Instead, behavior-based AI proposes that the agent be split up, not into disparate cognitive functionalities, but into “behaviors,” such as foraging, sleeping and hunting. Each of these behaviors would integrate all of the agent’s functions for that behavior.
Even such approaches, however, have not been entirely successful in building agents that integrate a wide range of behaviors. Rod Brooks, for example, has stated that one of the challenges of the field is to find a way to build an agent that can integrate many behaviors (he defines “many” as more than a dozen) [2]. Programmers can create robust, subtle, effective and expressive behaviors, but the agent’s overall behavior tends to fall apart gradually as more behaviors are combined. For small numbers of behaviors, this disintegration can be managed by the programmer, but as more behaviors are combined their interactions become so complex that they become at least time-consuming and at worst impossible to manage.